A prompt card students keep
Dr. Steve Troyer · November 17, 2026

Teachers, when your students use AI on schoolwork, most of them haven't had a teacher show them how. In RAND's 2025 survey of middle and high school students, over 80 percent said their teachers hadn't explicitly taught them how to use AI for schoolwork.
A small card can close part of that gap, and it builds on the rubric-first feedback routine from a few weeks back. These are 3 prompts I'd hand students to tape inside a notebook or pin to your class page. Each one tells the AI to coach and leaves the thinking with the student, and each comes with a check you can do in about 2 minutes.
The prompt matters more than students think. A Google DeepMind researcher put the default plainly to Chalkbeat: "By default, we train AI models to be helpful assistants that can do the work for the user." The card is how a student changes that.
Two things before you hand it out. Use it only on assignments where you've already said AI is allowed (and if families haven't heard how your class uses AI, here's a one-page note for that), and only in a tool your school allows students to use. And students keep names and personal details out of anything they paste.
Prompt 1: Coach, don't fix
When: a student has a draft and wants feedback.
What they paste: their draft and the rubric or assignment directions.
Here is my draft and the rubric for the assignment. Don't rewrite any of it and don't give me new sentences. Tell me which part of the rubric my draft is furthest from, point to the place in my draft that shows it, and ask me one question that would help me fix it myself.
The 2-minute check: have students copy the AI's question onto the top of their next draft. Read just the questions. If a "question" is really a rewritten sentence, the student either skipped the card or the tool ignored it, and both are worth a quick word.
Prompt 2: Edit, then judge
This one comes from a French teacher. MIT Technology Review reported that Miriam Przybyla-Baum, who teaches at Cheshire Academy in Connecticut and doesn't use AI herself, has her students let AI edit their homework. Then they go through the edits and decide which ones were correct and which ones "removed their voice."
What they paste: a paragraph or short piece they've finished.
Here is a paragraph I wrote. Suggest up to 5 edits, numbered. For each one, show my original words and your change side by side, and tell me in one sentence why you'd make it. Don't change anything else.
Then the student marks every edit keep, change or reject, and writes a few words next to any edit that made it sound less like them.
The 2-minute check: read just the rejects. A student who rejects an edit and can say why is doing the judging you want. A page of nothing but keeps is worth a short conversation.
Prompt 3: Quiz me before I turn it in
What they paste: their finished work.
Here is my finished work. Ask me 3 questions about it, one at a time: what a key part means, why I made a choice I made, and what would change if one fact were different. Wait for my answer before you ask the next one. Don't give me the answers. After all 3, tell me which of my answers was weakest and why.
Students answer without looking back at their work.
The 2-minute check: at the door, ask one student one of those questions out loud. "Tell me what this paragraph means" takes 30 seconds, and after a few days you'll know whether the card is helping.
If your school uses Google Classroom
Google just added a way to put a coaching mode on the assignment itself. Teachers can now add Guided Learning to any Classroom assignment and pick sources from the class to use as context. Inside that assignment the regular Gemini side panel is hidden, new chats are turned off, and students stay in Guided Learning. Teachers can also read individual student chat transcripts. It's rolling out on Education Fundamentals, Standard and Plus, and Gemini has to be turned on for you and your students.
I'd still hand out the card. The setting covers one assignment in one tool. The card is a habit students carry to every other tool they use.
Making the card
Put the 3 prompts on a half sheet, each with its "when" line. Then walk through Prompt 1 together once, out loud, on a sample draft you wrote yourself. That 10 minutes is the AI lesson most of your students haven't had.
My one warning
The card doesn't replace your rule about when AI is allowed. A student who wants the answer can still ignore the prompt, and a tool can still slip and rewrite. Read what comes back. The judging is the part you're teaching.
Next week
What never goes into an AI tool, and a simple way to decide before you paste.
One question back
Which of the 3 prompts would your students push back on most? Email me and tell me.
EdTeacherAI is an independent newsletter and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any AI company.
Every workflow in the series, with the prompts and the review steps, in the free Field Guide.
Get the Field Guide, freeCommon questions
- What are good AI prompts for students?
- Prompts that tell the AI to coach and leave the work to the student: ask for one question instead of a rewrite, suggested edits the student has to judge, or a short quiz on their own work. Students should use them only in a tool the school allows and only when AI is allowed on the assignment.
- How do I check whether students used AI well?
- Look at what the prompt produced along with the final draft: the question the AI asked, the edits the student rejected and why, or the student's answer to one question about their own work. Each takes about 2 minutes.
- Can I put a coaching mode on a Google Classroom assignment?
- Yes. Google now lets teachers add Guided Learning to any Classroom assignment, with sources from the class as context, on Education Fundamentals, Standard and Plus. Gemini has to be turned on for the teacher and the students.
- Should students put personal information into AI tools?
- No. Students keep names and personal details out of anything they paste, and use only the AI tools the school allows them to use.